Journal of Linguistics and Language Teaching
Volume 17 (2026) Issue 2
From Awareness to Action: A Comparative Analysis of Ecoliteracy in Secondary Level English Textbooks of Telangana and West Bengal
Revathi Srinivas & Goutam Biswas (The English and Foreign Languages University, Hyderabad, India)
Abstract
This study compares the integration of ecoliteracy in English textbooks for classes IX and X of the Telangana State Board of Secondary Education (TSBSE) and the West Bengal Board of Secondary Education (WBBSE). Applying Saiful's (2024) Eco-ELT framework as its primary analytical tool, the research conceptualises ecoliteracy across six developmental phases – awareness, understanding, attitude, worldview, skills, and sustainable actions – while concurrently addressing language proficiency phases from exposure to performance. This application serves as an initial empirical validation of the novel framework within the under-researched context of Indian secondary education. Through qualitative content analysis, the findings reveal that while both boards incorporate environmental themes, Telangana's textbooks demonstrate a more integrated approach, embedding deeper ecological concerns and action-oriented tasks. The paper concludes by discussing the pedagogical implications for the holistic integration of Eco-ELT into Indian English language teaching curricula.
Keywords: Eco-ELT, ecoliteracy, textbook analysis, secondary education, curriculum development
1 Introduction
The climate crisis is no longer a distant threat but a lived reality. In such times, education – especially language education – must evolve to foster environmental sensitivity alongside linguistic competence. Ecological English Language Teaching (Eco-ELT) offers an integrated approach where environmental consciousness is developed through English language education. In India, school education is state-controlled, with Boards of Education designing textbooks that are central and often the sole resource around which teaching and learning are organised. While textbook analysis studies have explored themes like gender or nationalism, ecoliteracy in Indian English textbooks remains underexplored, particularly through the lens of Eco-ELT. This paper compares textbooks prescribed for study for students in classes IX and X English from Telangana and West Bengal, using Saiful’s (2024) Eco-ELT framework, which offers a more holistic and action-driven lens than earlier models like Roth’s (1992) ECAF. In this study, the term ecoliteracy is used consistently to denote the integration of environmental awareness, understanding, and action in language education. While terms such as environmental literacy (Roth, 1992) and ecological literacy (Capra, 2005) appear in prior research, they are conceptually aligned. Nevertheless, Saiful’s (2024) ecoliteracy is preferred here because it emphasises the ecological dimensions of English Language Teaching within the Eco-ELT framework.
2 Literature Review
2.1 The Trajectory of Environmental Content in ELT Materials
The integration of environmental themes into English Language Teaching (ELT) materials has evolved from a peripheral concern to a recognised imperative, with textbooks serving as a primary site for transmitting cultural and ecological values (Simpson, 1997). Early studies established that while environmental topics were present, their coverage was often minimal and superficial.
A foundational study by Jacobs & Goatly (2000) revealed that only 2% of activities in a random sample of 17 ELT coursebooks published since 1990 contained environmental content. More critically, they noted that these activities rarely encouraged active participation in resolving environmental issues. This trend of superficial engagement was further explored by Stibbe (2004) in an analysis of 26 EFL textbooks in Japan. Stibbe argued that the materials predominantly presented a shallow environmentalism, focussing on technological fixes for environmental symptoms (e.g., fuel-efficient cars for pollution) while failing to criticise the underlying cultural values and consumerist ideologies driving the crisis. He contrasted this with a ‘deep ecology’ perspective, which calls for fundamental cultural and political change.
This pattern of shallow environmentalism has been observed beyond Japan. In China, Xiong (2014) found that while environmental education was a government priority, its treatment in state-sanctioned EFL textbooks primarily served to raise awareness rather than foster active participation or transformational practice. Similarly, a recent study in Indonesia by Suwandi et al. (2024) applied Roth's (1992) Ecoliteracy Content Analysis Frame (ECAF) to language textbooks, finding an overemphasis on the knowledge aspect and a concerning absence of cognitive skills and affective tendencies in two of the four books analysed.
2.2 The Research Gap: From Shallow Environmentalism to Integrated Eco-ELT
While the above-mentioned studies successfully diagnose a prevalence of shallow environmentalism in ELT materials, they reveal a significant gap. Their analytical frameworks, including Roth's (1992) ECAF, are primarily content-focused and are not designed to evaluate the simultaneous development of language proficiency. These prior works did not systematically investigate whether environmental content was being used to teach all four language skills (listening, speaking, reading, and writing) in an integrated manner. Consequently, the field has lacked a comprehensive framework capable of concurrently addressing the development of ecological consciousness and language learning objectives within the specific context of ELT.
This gap is precisely what the Eco-ELT framework (Saiful, 2024) seeks to fill. Moving beyond Roth's categories of Knowledge, Affective Tendencies, Behaviour, and Cognitive Skills, Saiful's model proposes a dual-axis approach. It conceptualises ecoliteracy across six developmental phases of environmental well-being (Awareness, Understanding, Attitude, Worldview, Skills, and Sustainable Actions) while concurrently addressing four parallel phases of language proficiency (Exposure, Attitude, Communicative Competence, and Performance). It is this integrated, pedagogical lens that our study employs to analyse Indian textbooks, aiming not only to evaluate ecoliteracy content but also to understand its role in facilitating English language acquisition.
2.3 From Ecoliteracy to Eco-ELT: Evolution of the Analytical Framework
While Roth's (1992) ecoliteracy model (Knowledge, Affective Tendencies, Behaviour, and Cognitive Skills) provided a foundation, Saiful’s (2024) Eco-ELT framework represents a significant evolution tailored for language education. Building on Mete’s (2018) Bloom’s Taxonomy-based framework and incorporating Saiful’s (2024) emphasis on shaping ecocentric worldviews, the model also aligns with UNESCO’s environmental education goals and Monroe et al.’s (2007) practitioner categories. Saiful (2024) synthesises these preceding models into a dual-axis framework, featuring six developmental phases of environmental well-being (from Awareness to Sustainable Action) and four parallel phases of language proficiency (from Exposure to Performance). This integrated Eco-ELT framework serves as the analytical tool for this study, as detailed in Table 1:
Phase | The Well-being of the Natural Environment | Language Proficiency | Example Indicator |
1 | Developing awareness: environmental awareness | Providing rich exposures of English | Environmental fact collection, species identification |
2 | Developing understanding: knowledge about environment | Developing favourable language attitudes: what you believe, feel, and intend to do about English | Explaining ecological processes, interpreting environmental data |
3 | Developing attitudes: nature empathy and emotional entanglement with nature | Developing communicative competence | Conservation practices, role-play |
Table 1: Saiful’s (2024) Eco-ELT Analytical Framework
3 Methodology
3.1 Research Design
The present study employs a qualitative content analysis approach to examine four English textbooks from the West Bengal Board of Secondary Education (WBBSE) and the Telangana State Board of Secondary Education (TSBSE). As Krippendorff (2004: 18) defines it, content analysis is "a research technique for making replicable and valid inferences from texts to the contexts of their use." This method is suited for systematically evaluating the integration of both environmental well-being and language proficiency as conceptualised by the Eco-ELT framework.
3.2 Theoretical Framework and Justification
As mentioned above, this study is grounded in Saiful's (2024) Eco-ELT framework. This framework was selected for its integrated, dual-axis structure, which simultaneously analyses the development of ecological consciousness (across six phases) and language proficiency (across four phases). This makes it a significant advancement over earlier, non-ELT-specific models like Roth's (1992) ECAF. The credibility of the framework is anchored in its synthesis of established pedagogical and environmental education theories. Its environmental axis extends the foundational goals of UNESCO and the work of Monroe et al. (2007), while its cumulative structure mirrors the cognitive progression of Bloom's Revised Taxonomy (Anderson & Krathwohl, 2001). Its primary innovation is the integration of a parallel language proficiency axis, providing a holistic tool to evaluate not just the presence of ecological content, but its pedagogical role in achieving language learning objectives.
As a novel framework, Eco-ELT's application is prospective. This study represents an initial empirical test of its utility. Several considerations guided its application:
Non-linearity: We did not assume the phases represent a rigid sequence, but rather independent dimensions to be coded for.
Subjectivity: Distinguishing between closely related phases (e.g., "Attitudes" and "Worldviews") required strict operational definitions (for our purposes, “Attitudes” refers specifically to the affective, emotional connection – such as empathy or feelings of inclusion – with nature, whereas “Worldviews” refers to the cognitive and philosophical transition from anthropocentric (human-centred) to non-anthropocentric (ecocentric) perspectives) and high inter-coder reliability (κ = 0.87), as detailed in the data collection procedures.
Contextual Application: The framework's applicability across diverse Indian contexts was a central subject of this investigation.
3.3 Research Questions and Objectives
Textbooks are central to Indian classrooms. Research (Cunningsworth, 1995) emphasises that what is included – or omitted – in textbooks profoundly influences learner values. A critical Eco-ELT lens helps identify whether learners are being prepared not just to talk about nature but to act for it. In the current study, we investigated two research questions regarding environmental education in the four selected ELT coursebooks from the two boards:
To what extent do the selected ELT textbooks incorporate ecoliteracy topics, and how is this content integrated with the development of comprehensive language skills?
How do the textbooks from the West Bengal and Telangana state boards align with the phases of Saiful's (2024) Eco-ELT framework?
To address the research questions, this study pursued two primary objectives:
To identify and compare the representation of ecoliteracy elements in the textbooks prescribed for study for students in classes IX and X of the WBBSE and the TSBSE.
To evaluate the alignment of these textbooks with Saiful's (2024) Eco-ELT framework, assessing their progression through both the ecological and language proficiency phases.
3.4 Data Collection and Coding Procedures
The study analysed four English textbooks from Classes IX and X prescribed by the WBBSE and the TSBSE. These two states were selected to provide a compelling comparative case study based on their contrasting educational histories and socio-ecological contexts.
West Bengal represents a mature, traditional educational system with a curriculum deeply influenced by its literary heritage, emphasising classic literature and knowledge acquisition. In contrast, Telangana, a state formed in 2014, had the opportunity to develop a newer curriculum, potentially reflecting more contemporary, skills-oriented, and constructivist pedagogical approaches. This dichotomy allows us to investigate how different curricular philosophies influence the integration of modern frameworks like Eco-ELT.
Furthermore, their distinct environmental challenges provide a relevant backdrop: West Bengal is home to the climate-vulnerable Sundarbans delta, while Telangana faces acute water scarcity and has initiated large-scale afforestation programmes (Telangana Ku Haritha Haram). Thus, the selection enables an examination of how local ecological priorities are reflected in state-mandated textbooks.
A qualitative content analysis was conducted on all chapters of the four textbooks between January and July 2025. The unit of analysis varied by phase to reflect the nature of the content being coded. For the Exposure phase of language proficiency, the unit was a complete reading or listening text, as Exposure is best measured by the volume and variety of whole texts provided to learners. For all remaining ecoliteracy and language proficiency phases, the unit was a sentence, paragraph, or discrete activity, that is, any self-contained textual element whose thematic or pedagogical content aligned with a given phase. In the Appendices (Tables A1 and B1), page references are provided as locators for these coded units, not as the unit of measurement itself. This distinction is maintained consistently across the frequency tables and the appendices.
To ensure reliability, the primary researcher coded all chapters. A second ELT expert independently coded a 50% subset (9 chapters). Inter-rater agreement, calculated using Cohen's Kappa, reached 0.87, indicating a high level of agreement. All discrepancies were resolved through discussion to reach a final consensus.
The analysis included any textual content (e.g., reading texts, exercises, assignments, questions) that addressed environmental issues, defined as themes related to ecological awareness, understanding, or action (e.g., endangered species, conservation, sustainability). Content was included regardless of its primary pedagogical focus (e.g., a grammar exercise was included if its thematic content was environmental).
The study excluded the following:
Standalone tests and examinations.
Visual elements (images, charts, diagrams) and their captions, even if they supported environmental content. This exclusion was a deliberate methodological decision: since the Eco-ELT framework's language proficiency phases (Exposure, Attitude, Communicative Competence, and Performance) are operationalised through textual and task-based evidence, the inclusion of visual elements would have introduced a layer of interpretation that could not be coded with the same inter-rater reliability as textual content. The exclusion is acknowledged as a limitation of the study, and future research employing multimodal discourse analysis frameworks would be better positioned to account for the role of visual content in ecoliteracy pedagogy.
Content where the environmental connection was tangential or incidental.
This exclusion acknowledges a significant analytical limitation. While visual literacy is crucial for modern curricula, the study's decision to focus on textual evidence for the sake of inter-rater reliability necessitates that conclusions regarding the 'holistic' nature of the curriculum be interpreted as pertaining primarily to textual and task-based pedagogical content. This adjustment addresses the potential analytical blind spot between the exclusion criteria and the broader claims regarding curricular integration.
The coded data were analysed using a mixed-methods approach. Quantitatively, frequency counts and percentages were calculated to determine the distribution of ecoliteracy and language proficiency phases across the textbooks. Qualitatively, a comparative analysis was conducted to interpret the pedagogical patterns, with a specific focus on identifying the depth of engagement (e.g., a focus on lower-order awareness vs. higher-order action) and the integration of ecological and linguistic objectives in each board's curriculum.
A systematic coding process was applied to every unit (including prose, poetry, activities, and questions) across all four textbooks. Each unit was analysed for textual content corresponding to the phases of Saiful's (2024) ecoliteracy and language proficiency frameworks. To ensure reliability, two coders independently analysed the entire dataset. The high inter-rater agreement (Cohen’s κ = 0.87) confirms the consistent application of the coding scheme. While a complete quantitative summary is provided in Tables 3 and 4, the analysis below employs illustrative examples. These examples were strategically selected to demonstrate the application of the framework across different genres (poetry, prose, drama), to represent both lower and higher-order ecoliteracy phases, and to illuminate the key contrasts identified between the two state boards.
The following table provides an overview of the specific English textbooks selected for analysis in this study, detailing their publication sources and editions:
Title of The Book | Publisher / Board | Year of Publication |
Bliss-IX | The West Bengal Board of Secondary Education, Department of School Education, Kolkata, The Government of West Bengal. | First Edition: December 2014 |
Bliss-X | The West Bengal Board of Secondary Education, Department of School Education, Kolkata, The Government of West Bengal. | First Edition: December 2015 Second Edition: December 2016 Third Edition: December 2017 |
Our World Through English-IX | The Telangana State Board of Secondary Education, Department of School Education, Hyderabad, The Government of Telangana. | First Published 2013 New Impressions 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019 |
Our World Through English-X | The Telangana State Board of Secondary Education, Department of School Education, Hyderabad, The Government of Telangana. | First Published 2014 New Impression 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020 |
Table 2: Textbook profile
4 Results
4.1 Data Analysis and Interpretation
The analysis revealed distinct patterns in how each board integrates ecoliteracy and language proficiency. Table 3 summarises the frequency distribution across Saiful's (2024) six ecoliteracy phases:
Textbook | Aware- ness | Under- standing | Attitude | World- view | Skills | Actions | Total |
WBBSE Bliss-IX | 5 (38.5%) | 4 (30.8%) | 4 (30.8%) | 0 (0%) | 0 (0%) | 0 (0%) | 13 |
WBBSE Bliss-X | 4 (44.4%) | 3 (33.3%) | 1 (11.1%) | 1 (11.1%) | 0 (0%) | 0 (0%) | 9 |
TSBSE Our World-IX | 6 (30.0%) | 5 (25.0%) | 3 (15.0%) | 1 (5.0%) | 3 (15.0%) | 2 (10.0%) | 20 |
TSBSE Our World-X | 5 (31.3%) | 5 (31.3%) | 1 (6.2%) | 1 (6.2%) | 2 (12.5%) | 2 (12.5%) | 16 |
Table 3: Frequency Distribution of Ecoliteracy Elements
Table 4 shows the language proficiency elements:
Textbook | Exposure | Attitude | Commu- nicative Compe- tence | Language Perfor- mance | Total |
WBBSE Bliss-IX | 12 (52.2%) | 11 (47.8%) | 0 (0%) | 0 (0%) | 23 |
WBBSE Bliss-X | 8 (50.0%) | 8 (50.0%) | 0 (0%) | 0 (0%) | 16 |
TSBSE Our World-IX | 32 (59.3%) | 8 (14.8%) | 8 (14.8%) | 6 (11.1%) | 54 |
TSBSE Our World-X | 32 (59.3%) | 7 (13.0%) | 8 (14.8%) | 7 (13.0%) | 54 |
Table 4: Frequency Distribution of Language Proficiency Elements
The Exposure phase was calculated based on the total number of reading and listening texts. For all other phases, the unit of analysis was a sentence, paragraph, or discrete activity; page numbers in Appendix Tables A1 and B1 serve as locators for these coded units.
4.2 Patterns in Ecoliteracy Integration
The WBBSE textbooks predominantly engage with lower-order ecoliteracy phases. For instance, Bliss-IX (p. 18) uses the poem Autumn to build environmental Awareness through descriptive nature imagery, while a passage about catastrophic climate change (p. 39) develops Understanding of environmental crises. However, these textbooks show minimal progression to higher-order phases, with only one instance of Worldview development across both grades (Bliss-X, p. 31), and completely lack Skills and Sustainable Actions.
In contrast, TSBSE textbooks demonstrate progression through all six ecoliteracy phases. While they also include awareness-building content, they uniquely incorporate tasks that develop practical Skills, such as conducting water audits (Our World-IX, p. 85), and enable Sustainable Actions like fundraising for environmental relief (Our World-IX, p. 96) and advocating for tree planting (Our World-X, p. 116).
4.3 Patterns in Language Proficiency Integration
A similar divergence appears in language development. WBBSE (Bliss-IX and Bliss-X) focuses on Exposure through literary texts and fosters positive Language Attitude through creative writing tasks. However, it lacks activities for developing Communicative Competence or enabling Language Performance.
TSBSE textbooks (Our World-IX and Our World-X), however, systematically address all four language proficiency phases. Beyond exposure, they include project-based learning that requires Communicative Competence (e.g., data collection tasks, Our World-IX, p. 23) and enable Language Performance through integrated tasks like debates and report-writing (Our World-IX, p. 108; Our World-X, p. 192).
Detailed page references and textual evidence for these proficiency phases across all four textbooks are provided in Table B1 in Appendix B.
5 Discussion
This study investigated the integration of ecoliteracy in Indian ELT textbooks through the lens of Saiful's (2024) Eco-ELT framework. The findings reveal a significant divergence in pedagogical execution between the textbooks of these two state boards. The WBBSE curriculum, as evidenced by the data for the Bliss series in Table 3, aligns with a traditional, knowledge-centric model. Its primary strength lies in building environmental Awareness (38.5% in Bliss-IX and 44.4% in Bliss-X) and Understanding through literary exposure. However, its lack of progression into the phases of Skills and Sustainable Actions confirms a shallow environmentalism (Stibbe, 2004), where the environment is treated as a descriptive theme rather than a system requiring active problem-solving.
Conversely, the TSBSE Our World Through English textbooks exemplify a modern, constructivist, and skills-based approach. As demonstrated in Table 3 and Table 4 above, this curriculum systematically progresses through all six ecoliteracy phases and four language proficiency phases. The shift from Awareness to Action is validated by the presence of practical tasks, such as the water audits (p. 85) and advocacy campaigns (p. 116) reported in Section 4.2. These integrated tasks ensure that English language acquisition is not an abstract exercise but a functional tool for real-world environmental engagement. This enables students to move beyond linguistic competence to communicative performance, fulfilling the dual-axis objectives of the Eco-ELT framework.
Furthermore, this study serves as a successful initial validation of the Eco-ELT framework. The framework proved to be a sensitive and powerful diagnostic tool, capable of distinguishing not only the presence of environmental content, but also the depth of its pedagogical integration. The clear, quantifiable clustering of the two sets of textbooks at opposite ends of the framework's phases attests to its utility for comparative curriculum analysis and its potential to guide future materials development.
The application of the Eco-ELT framework revealed clear, quantifiable differences between the two sets of textbooks. As shown in Table 3 above, the WBBSE textbooks clustered exclusively in the lower-order phases of Awareness and Understanding, while the TSBSE textbooks demonstrated presence across all the six phases. Similarly, Table 4 shows that WBBSE textbooks were confined to Exposure and Attitude, whereas TSBSE textbooks included Communicative Competence and Language Performance. This clustering suggests that the framework can effectively distinguish between curricula that treat environmental content superficially and those that integrate it across cognitive and linguistic dimensions.
This finding addresses the gap identified in Section 2.2, where earlier frameworks like Roth's (1992) ECAF were noted to be content-focused and unable to capture the simultaneous development of language proficiency. The Eco-ELT framework's dual-axis approach allowed for a more holistic evaluation, revealing not just what environmental content was present, but how it was pedagogically integrated with language learning objectives.
The framework's ability to diagnose gaps in both ecological and linguistic dimensions suggests its utility for materials development. For instance, the absence of Skills and Sustainable Actions in the WBBSE textbooks, and the presence of these phases in the TSBSE textbooks, indicates areas where curriculum designers could focus their efforts to achieve more holistic integration.
6 Conclusion
This comparative analysis has demonstrated that the English textbooks of Telangana and West Bengal, while both containing elements of ecoliteracy, serve fundamentally different educational paradigms. The TSBSE curriculum, through its systematic integration of action-oriented tasks (e.g., water audits, p. 85; advocacy campaigns, p. 116), as detailed in our analysis of textbook activities, is designed to prepare students to use English as a means for ecological thought and sustainable action. The WBBSE curriculum, while rich in literary value, primarily prepares students to encounter nature as a thematic subject in the realm of the English language.
The implications of this study are significant for curriculum designers, teacher educators, and policymakers across India. The systematic integration of ecoliteracy across all six developmental phases observed in the TSBSE textbooks directly aligns with the cross-curricular approach to environmental education and the focus on critical thinking and holistic development championed by the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020. Furthermore, this pedagogical model supports broader national and global sustainability goals by equipping students not merely with knowledge, but with the skills and agency to become active participants in creating a sustainable future. The findings suggest that moving beyond a literature-dominated syllabus towards project-based, skills-integrated tasks – such as the data collection activities, debates, and report writing demonstrated in the TSBSE curriculum – can more effectively develop the ecologically literate and linguistically competent citizens that the 21st century demands.
In conclusion, this study not only maps the ecoliteracy scope of two major Indian states but also provides a replicable model for future research.
Appendices
Appendix A: Detailed Coding of Ecoliteracy Elements
Textbook | Aware- ness | Under- standing | Attitude | Worldview | Skills | Actions |
WBBSE Bliss-IX | 18, 26, 33, 39, 68 | 26, 33, 68, 92 | 7, 17, 18, 82 | – | – | – |
WBBSE Bliss-X | 6, 48, 53, 62 | 5, 53, 62 | 5 | 31 | – | – |
TSBSE Our World-IX | 75, 89, 97, 100, 103 | 66, 70, 76, 90, 102 | 68, 79, 82 | 69 | 76, 85, 105 | 96, 103 |
TSBSE Our World-X | 165, 180, 186, 189, 191 | 165, 166, 181, 184, 185 | 169 | 181 | 179, 192 | 116, 192 |
Note: The figures in the table refer to the respective page numbers. The hyphen (–) indicates that no instances were coded for that phase.
Table A1: Textbook Passages Coded by Ecoliteracy Phase
Appendix B: Detailed Coding of Language Proficiency Elements
Textbook | Exposure | Attitude | Communicative Competence | Language Performance |
WBBSE Bliss-IX | 12 | 7, 17, 33, 44, 49, 60, 68, 74, 82, 91, 96 | – | – |
WBBSE Bliss-X | 8 | 11, 15, 30, 36, 47, 52, 61, 65 | – | – |
TSBSE Our World-IX | 32 | 14, 34, 43, 58, 79, 85, 93, 97 | 23, 43, 63, 86, 105, 125, 146, 164 | 35, 43, 46, 108, 116, 124 |
TSBSE Our World-X | 32 | 22, 63, 85, 114, 125, 208, 231 | 29, 72, 97, 130, 160, 192, 220, 248 | 2, 21, 96, 164, 220, 231, 235 |
Note: The figures in the table refer to the respective page numbers. The hyphen (–) indicates that no instances were coded for that phase. Exposure was calculated based on the total number of reading and listening texts.
Table B1: Textbook Passages Coded by Language Proficiency Phases
References
Anderson, L. W., & Krathwohl, D. R. (Eds.). (2001). A taxonomy for learning, teaching, and assessing: A revision of Bloom’s taxonomy of educational objectives. Longman.
Capra, F. (2005). Speaking nature’s language: Principles for sustainability. Schumacher College.
Cunningsworth, A. (1995). Choosing your coursebook. Heinemann.
Jacobs, G. M., & Goatly, A. (2000). The treatment of ecological issues in ELT coursebooks. ELT Journal, 54(3), 256–264. https://doi.org/10.1093/elt/54.3.256
Krippendorff, K. (2004). Content analysis: An introduction to its methodology (2nd ed.). Sage.
Mete, D. E. (2018). Incorporating environmental education in English language teaching through Bloom’s Revised Taxonomy. Selçuk Üniversitesi Edebiyat Fakültesi Dergisi (SEFAD), 40, 33–44. https://doi.org/10.21497/sefad.514847
Monroe, M. C., Andrews, E., & Biedenweg, K. (2007). A framework for environmental education strategies. Applied Environmental Education & Communication, 6(3–4), 205–216.
Roth, C. E. (1992). Environmental literacy: Its roots, evolution, and directions in the 1990s. ERIC/CSMEE.
Saiful, J. A. (2024). Eco-ELT: Trends and developments in the study and practice of environmental education within English language teaching. PT Literasi Nusantara Abadi Grup.
Simpson, P. (1997). Language through literature: An introduction. Routledge.
Stibbe, A. (2004). Environmental education across cultures: Beyond the discourse of shallow environmentalism. Language and Intercultural Communication, 4(4), 242–260.
Suwandi, S., Drajati, N. A., Handayani, A., & Tyarakanita, A. (2024). The analysis of ecoliteracy elements in language textbooks. Cogent Education, 11(1), 2300907. https://doi.org/10.1080/2331186X.2023.2300907
Xiong, T. (2014). Shallow environmentalism: A preliminary eco-critical discourse analysis of secondary school English as a foreign language (EFL) texts in China. The Journal of Environmental Education, 45(4), 232–242.
Primary Data Sources
The Telangana State Board of Secondary Education. (2013). Our world through English-IX. Department of School Education, Government of Telangana.
The Telangana State Board of Secondary Education. (2014). Our world through English-X. Department of School Education, Government of Telangana.
The West Bengal Board of Secondary Education. (2014). Bliss-IX. Department of School Education, Government of West Bengal.
The West Bengal Board of Secondary Education. (2015). Bliss-X. Department of School Education, Government of West Bengal.
Authors:
Prof. Revathi Srinivas
Ph.D., Fulbright-Nehru Postdoctoral Fellow
Department of Materials Development, Testing, and Evaluation
The English and Foreign Languages University
Hyderabad
India
Email: revathi@efluniversity.ac.in.
ORCID-ID: 0009-0008-9593-1401
Goutam Biswas
Post Graduate Diploma in the Teaching of English (PGDTE)
The English and Foreign Languages University
Hyderabad
India
Email: goutambiswas06082001@gmail.com